Volume 3
Alongside detectives and journalists, family members offer clues, present theories, and identify suspects, hoping one viewer holds the key to solving the mystery.
01. Mystery at Mile Marker 45
Teen athlete Tiffany Valiante is struck by a train; police rule it a suicide, but her family believes she was murdered.
02. Something in the Sky
Hundreds of people in Michigan report strange lights over Lake Michigan on March 8, 1994.
03. Body in Bags
David Carter is murdered and dismembered; his girlfriend, the primary suspect, flees and remains a fugitive.
04. Death in a Vegas Motel
"Buffalo Jim" Barrier, a local Vegas personality, dies in a motel under suspicious circumstances involving the mob.
05. Paranormal Rangers
Navajo Rangers share their investigations into Bigfoot, skinwalkers, and UFOs on tribal lands.
06. What Happened to Josh?
College student Josh Guimond disappears after a party; new digital evidence suggests a darker side to the case.
07. Body in the Bay
Patrick Mullins' boat is found adrift; his body is later found weighted down in shallow water.
08. The Ghost in Apt. 14
A woman believes her apartment is haunted by a victim of a 1970s serial killer
09. Abducted by a Parent
Explores two cases where children were taken by a non-custodial parent, leaving the other parent in a decades-long search.